Don't Be Taken In By The Grief Industry

Commentary

Good Grief: Don't Get Taken
By the Trauma Industry

By Sally Satel and Christina Hoff Sommers. Dr. Satel is a psychiatrist and Ms. Sommers is a philosopher. They are scholars at the American Enterprise Institute.

Did the Sept. 11 attacks on New York and Washington trigger a national mental health crisis? Many psychiatrists, psychologists and grief counselors think so. They warn that the nation faces an epidemic of depression and post-traumatic stress.

Companies are being deluged with offers from grief counseling firms insisting that their services are vital for the well-being of all employees. The president of the New York Psychiatric Association says that many who watched televised images of the planes flying into the World Trade Center can expect psychiatric problems. Another psychiatrist cautions that witnessing the disaster on TV plus worrying about more conflict "add up to a critical public health challenge for our country." And, said the president of the National Mental Health Association, "What our country really needs -- now more than ever -- is a complete mental health infrastructure."

The good will of these professionals and firms -- Crisis Management International, International Critical Incident Stress Foundation, Corporate Counseling Associates, and COPE, Inc., to name a few -- is not in doubt.

[Karl Note:  Just like we have NOT taken seriously enough the many terrorists pronouncements about what they were going to do, we still do not recognize the evil done by psychiatrists.  There IS no good intention here among the so-called "grief counselors,"  none!\]

But they exaggerate their own importance. Many individuals -- chiefly those directly affected by the atrocities -- may well have been traumatized to the point of needing therapeutic intervention. The nation as a whole has not. And managers should avoid the impulse to jump on the bandwagon and automatically contract with crisis counselors to show their sensitivity.

It is true that the attacks filled all of us with powerful, even overpowering, emotions. But as the renowned psychiatrist and Holocaust survivor Viktor Frankl pointed out, "Suffering is not always a pathological phenomenon... suffering may well be a human achievement, especially if grows out of existential frustration." In other words, suffering is often ennobling and strengthening.

[Karl Note:  This is more crap!  Yes, you can feel upset at the death of someone close -- but "feeling bad" is never a therapy that has value.  Instead, far more therapeutic, would be working in the yard, washing dishes, doing something useful -- you must get your attention OUTWARD, not be looking INWARD.  Looking inward will just spin you in to countless other times of upset.  The psychiatrists have only a harmful technology -- avoid it completely.]

It is in this spirit that Time writer Lance Morrow recently wrote, "For once, let's have no grief counselors standing by with banal consolations, as if the purpose, in the midst of all this, were merely to make everyone feel better as quickly as possible. We shouldn't feel better."

Nor do all of us need therapy. When asked if he wanted counseling, Richard A. Grasso, chairman of the New York Stock Exchange, replied sharply, "No, I don't need it. My counseling is this: that Monday morning 9:30 bell." A story in the New York Times reports that even most school children in New York City are resisting counselors' attention. "The students are saying, 'Can't we just do math?' " according to Dr. Ricky Greenwald from Mt. Sinai Hospital's Child Trauma Program.

This is not to deny a legitimate place for mental health experts in the tragedy's aftermath, [Karl Note:  There is no such place.] but their work is primarily local in scope, not national. Epidemiological evidence tells us that between 10% and 25% of those who confront harrowing, cataclysmic experiences -- barely escaping death at ground zero, for example -- may well develop clinical post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) within three months. Symptoms can include marked withdrawal from society, intense re-experiencing of the event (relentless nightmares and waking images), crippling anxiety and phobias. Cognitive-behavioral techniques and medications for PTSD are tested and effective.

Unfortunately, other interventions employed are far less reliable. Practitioners who call themselves "debriefers" are ubiquitous in New York City. They are part of a trauma industry that blossomed in the wake of the Oklahoma City bombing and Columbine shootings. Many saw their job as getting victims to express their feelings about the event -- to cry and relive it as vividly as they could.

The worst debriefers can be so intrusive that a group of 19 psychologists sent an open letter to their professional colleagues cautioning that, although "our instinct is to help, it is imperative that we refrain from the urge to intervene in ways that, however well-intentioned, have the potential to make matters worse." The signatories, among them some prominent specialists on the psychological effects of trauma, cited studies showing that certain crisis intervention techniques that emphasize the release of emotions and reliving the event had either no benefit or were actually harmful because they impeded recovery.

The best bet for managers is to learn the early warning signs of serious mental conditions -- not-for-profit mental health agencies can teach them what to look for -- and then to refer employees in need of treatment on a case by case basis.

[Karl Note:  No way! The best bet for managers is to increase the work schedule -- people need to be productive -- working -- not sitting around wailing!]

Yet the experts abound. New York City Schools Chancellor Harold O. Levy commissioned a mental health tip sheet from "leading child trauma experts" that he distributed to the city's 80,000 teachers. Among the pointers: "Avoid clichés such as 'Be strong.'" But why? Strength and courage are exactly what the country needs. The shadowy enemies we face are difficult to engage. However, their beliefs and intentions are clear enough. They abhor our devotion to a Judeo-Christian ethic, our commitment to Enlightenment principles of human dignity, individual liberty, and resulting economic creativity. With terrorist enemies, we need a clear, forceful response -- not therapeutic intercessions.

In a 1943 address at Harvard University, Winston Churchill praised his American allies: "How fortunate it was for the world that when these great trials came upon it there was a generation that terror could not conquer and brutal violence could not enslave." The good news is that just such a spirit of resolve turns out to be very much alive in America today, despite decades of moral drift.

The sensationalizing mental health professionals and journalists have mistaken the mood of the country. Americans do, indeed, feel a new and dismaying vulnerability, but that feeling should not be confused with helplessness, panic or the need for therapy on a grand scale. What we need -- and thankfully seem to have -- is a morally galvanized and focused citizenry, not a population turned inward on its alleged psychological fragility.

URL for this Article:
http://interactive.wsj.com/archive/retrieve.cgi?id=SB100309452173501960.djm
 

For information about subscribing, go to http://wsj.com

SUBSCRIBE:  The Wednesday Letter is a free electronic monthly newsletter written and published by Karl Loren.  You can view more than 50 back issues of this publication by clicking here.  The Wednesday Letter subscription list is maintained on a secure server, no name is ever given or sold to anyone, and it is never used except for this Newsletter.  It is automatically published on the Tuesday night just before the first Wednesday of every month.  You can subscribe to this free monthly electronic letter by entering your eMail address and name below.  You will then automatically receive a request for confirmation, sent to whatever address you have entered.  If you do NOT receive this confirmation request, then you will not be subscribed.  There may have been an error with your address and you should resubmit.  The letter is never sent twice to the same address -- so you do not have to worry about a duplicate subscription.  When you receive this confirmation request you must reply to it, or your subscription will not become active.  No one can subscribe your name, and address, without you being notified, and if you get an unwanted notice of subscription you only need to DO NOTHING and the subscription will NOT be active.

REMOVAL:  You can remove yourself from the subscription list in several different ways.  Click here to read about this entire newsletter system.  Every edition of The Wednesday Letter is delivered to your address with YOUR name and address in view on the letter, with a link that allows you to remove THAT name from the subscription list.  If you try to send this removal message from an address different from the one you used to send in your original confirmation, then you will get a warning notice first, sent to the subscription address, asking you to confirm that you want to be removed from the list -- by replying to THAT request for confirmation, you will then be automatically removed.  Thus, no one else can unsubscribe you, from some other computer, without your knowledge.  But, if you send in the unsubscribe notice from the same machine used to receive the Letter, then the removal from the subscription list is automatic.

Personal Message:  When you send a personal message to Karl Loren, you will receive a personal reply as per his instructions.  Karl pledges that every personal message will get a personal answer. When you provide your mail address, we will send you free information including our free catalog and a cassette tape lecture by Karl Loren about heart disease, no charge, by mail, even if outside the US.  You can select particular information you would like to receive, along with the free cassette tape and catalog.

You can reach Vibrant Life in many ways, including by mail to Vibrant Life, 2808 N. Naomi St., Burbank, CA 91504.  Within the US and Canada, use the toll free number:  (800) 523-4521, the local number:  (818) 558-1799, the FAX:  (818) 558-7299, eMail to kimberly@oralchelation.com or any one of the hundreds of message forms throughout the 50 web sites.  Vibrant Life normally ships the same day we get an order.  There are message forms on each of the 100,000+ pages on this and other sites where you can communicate with Vibrant Life.  Check out our companion site, at:  http://www.oralchelation.net where Karl's 2000 page book is published.  Karl Loren is the author and webmaster for this BOOK, as well as for another web site about ORAL CHELATION.  His personal philosophical articles are at PHILOSOPHY. 

Copyright © May 20, 2008 6:25 AM by Karl Loren on behalf of Vibrant Life, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.  Permission is granted for non-commercial downloading, copying, distribution or redistribution on two conditions:  One, that some form of copyright notice is included in every copy distributed or copied, showing the copyright belonging to Vibrant Life, Burbank, CA, at www.oralchelation.com . The second condition is that the material is not to be used for any purpose contrary to the purposes and objectives of this site.  This permission does not extend to materials on this site which are copyrighted by others.